What Gets Lost Between a Strategic Decision and Its Impact

The philosopher Bertrand Russell distinguished between two types of knowledge. This distinction describes, with remarkable precision, the biggest problem in strategy implementation—as detailed in the following “Success Insight” by our guest author Volkmar Völzke.

People know how to do it, but they don't put it into practice: a common gap between strategic decisions and results. (Image: Depositphotos.com)

Bertrand Russell, a British logician, mathematician, and Nobel Prize laureate, distinguished between two forms of knowledge: «knowing that» and «knowing how.» The knowledge that something is true. And the knowledge of how to actually do it.

When it comes to the question of why so many strategy processes fail to have an impact, this is the most precise distinction I have ever encountered.

The familiar pattern

I’ve observed this in practice for years: The workshop was well-structured, the analysis was sound, and the energy in the room was palpable. Everyone agreed. Three months later, everyone is back to working as before. An analysis by the Fraunhofer Institute confirms this pattern: Most strategic initiatives lose momentum between the decision and concrete action.

The team knows that the strategy is sound. What’s missing is the «know-how»—the knowledge, reflected in their behavior, of how to actually act differently on a daily basis than they have in the past.

Three causes that almost always occur

  • Agreement is not a commitment. Anyone who reverts to old habits at the first sign of real resistance after the workshop was never really on board to begin with. Agreeing in a meeting and acting consistently in everyday life are two different things. This becomes clear by week three at the latest.
  • New priorities require a "stop" list. Organizations almost always expand. New initiatives are added, while old ones remain in place. If no one decides what to eliminate, everyone decides for themselves. The result is predictable: the strategy ends up spread across twenty different projects at once.
  • Big goals require a change in attitude. Those who set growth goals but operate with yesterday’s mindset create internal contradictions every day. The real question is: What kind of team do you need to build to make that big goal achievable in two years?

What this means in practice

Simply knowing that a strategy is correct isn't enough. How to act—every day, in specific situations, under pressure—that is the other form of knowledge. It comes from consistency and from leaders who lead by example, demonstrating what they expect from their team.

Three questions for reflection:

  • What specific changes have taken place in your team during the first few weeks following the last strategy workshop? Which behaviors have actually changed?
  • What's on your "stop" list? Do you have one?
  • Who would need to be on your team to ensure that the big goal is actually achieved in two years?

Throughout his life, Russell asked questions that were uncomfortably precise. In the strategic planning process, it is precisely this precision that is most often lacking.

To the author:
Volkmar Völzke is a success maximizer. Book author. Consultant. Coach. Speaker. www.volkmarvoelzke.ch

(Visited 311 times, 1 visits today)

More articles on the topic