5 Criteria Companies Use to Identify Good Leadership
Uncertain markets, technological upheavals, and increasing complexity present companies with a key question: How can organizations remain capable of acting when the operating environment changes radically? An expert outlines five criteria.
«Good leadership, in the sense of shaping the context, plays a crucial role. Leaders create the conditions under which people can realize their potential, take on responsibility, and enable organizations to respond to change,» says Christine Trimpel, a biologist, transformation consultant, and partner at Masterpiece, a Frankfurt-based executive search firm. Accordingly, the range of KPIs is also expanding. Instead of merely measuring traditional performance metrics such as output, goal achievement, and short-term efficiency, five additional criteria should also be taken into account.
Independence Within a Team
«A key hallmark of good leadership is the team’s autonomy within its area of responsibility,» the expert emphasizes. This requires leaders who provide direction, clarify priorities, and create a reliable framework in which employees have sufficient freedom to make decisions. The more teams are able to solve problems independently and take on responsibility, the less the organization depends on individual people. This is especially crucial in complex, dynamic situations. «If every decision must first pass through several levels of the hierarchy, a company loses speed and responsiveness,» says Trimpel.
A Constructive Culture of Learning from Mistakes
Trying to completely prevent mistakes is neither realistic nor sensible. «What matters far more is how they are handled,» Trimpel emphasizes. Can employees address problems early on? Are negative trends becoming apparent? Does the team learn from its experiences? «If the answer to these questions is no, employees may need more psychological safety,» explains the expert. After all, they must be able to trust that critical feedback, doubts, or mistakes will not automatically lead to negative personal consequences. For this reason, it can be helpful for companies to also consider qualitative employee surveys, team diagnostics, or turnover patterns. For example, an unusually high turnover rate among top performers could indicate that while current leadership may be achieving short-term results, it is losing stability in the long run.
Ability to Learn and Adapt
Today, companies operate in an environment that is significantly less predictable. «Technological changes, new business models, shifting customer demands, or geopolitical developments can call existing assumptions into question within a short period of time,» Trimpel emphasizes. This also changes the role of leadership. In stable environments, standardization, control, and processes that were as reliable as possible were key success factors. «In dynamic markets, organizations must learn and adapt to new conditions,» adds the transformation expert. «Good leadership therefore creates space for reflection, learning, and professional development. It enables teams to evaluate experiences, test new solutions, and challenge established practices when necessary.»
Quality of Collaboration and Networking
«Companies are complex systems made up of various departments with different functions and interfaces. That’s why how collaboration works across these boundaries is also crucial,» Trimpel explains. Good leadership fosters exchange, cooperation, and sustainable relationships between different departments. For this reason, the assessment of leadership qualities should not be limited to the logic of organizational charts. Network analyses, collaboration patterns, or the quality of key interfaces, for example, can provide insights into how well knowledge circulates within a company.
Unlocking Potential
One of the most important questions when evaluating leadership is: What is this leader helping to develop? An answer to this question should always shed light on people and structures, in addition to business results. «Possible indicators of this include, for example, successful succession planning, talent retention, learning progress, or the increasing assumption of responsibility within a team,» emphasizes Trimpel. He notes that it is particularly telling whether an organization remains effective even when an individual leader leaves their position. This is precisely where sustainable leadership differs from short-term performance. «A leader who remains indispensable in the long term may have created dependencies. A leader who develops people and strengthens structures, on the other hand, leaves behind a system that functions even without constant oversight,» explains the expert.
Source: Masterpiece
This article originally appeared on m-q.ch - https://www.m-q.ch/de/5-kriterien-an-denen-unternehmen-gute-fuehrung-erkennen/
